The Observer, April 4, 2008
Volume XL, Issue 23
Posner's claims are unsubstantiated, unfair
To the Editor:
I am writing in response to Caleb Posner's editorial "Anti-Semitism strong at Case." Unfortunately, from the start, Posner makes it clear that he is far from being interested in the "intellectual growth," open debate, and dialogue that he claims to support. Instead, he makes serious allegations of racism that he provides no valid support for – something that is required of any serious scholar. Charging someone with bringing "vile, intellectually corrupt, and dishonest brokers of hate" to campus is a very dangerous accusation that Posner has made too easily. The subjective opinion of others is not sufficient proof by any standards, and the controversial professor Alan Dershowitz and equally controversial Anti-Defamation League are no exceptions.
Posner continues his piece with unsupported accusations against Case professor Alice Bach for her efforts to educate students on injustices that Palestinians are subjected to. Having an opinion different from Posner's does not legitimize such a character attack, and criticizing the actions of a state cannot be classified as "slander." He is also wrong to claim that Bach is the faculty sponsor of Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP). His baseless quoting of an unqualified source also stepped far beyond the bounds of acceptable criticism by labeling the SJP as being "dishonest," "dangerous," and "deadly." His overall argument that the Case environment is imbalanced against Israel, is highly questionable, considering public, unabashed support given to Israel and visits to the campus by significant Israeli speakers. In conclusion, Posner has stepped far beyond the bounds of freedom of speech that is protected by the First Amendment and may have stepped into the bounds of libel. Contrary to his claims, he appears to be attempting to stifle freedom of expression and is aiming to silence any view on campus that does not fall solidly within his one-sided, pro-Israel views that even many Israelis do not agree with. It is unfortunate that The Observer has published such an unacceptable and baseless assault on students, scholars, and others, and damaged Case's reputation with a title alleging anti-Semitism. I hope that it sets up higher standards for its editorials, and issues an apology to the victims of Posner's editorial. Expressing one's support for Israel is acceptable and welcome for an open society and campus. Calling those who disagree with one's view racists and making other unsubstantiated character attacks are not.
Ali Assar
Undergraduate student
