Recently, I was volunteering at the University Hospitals clinic. My role consists of reading books to children and encouraging them to read along. As I was reading a book to a five-year-old girl, she mentioned that she had a cell phone. Intrigued, I asked her if it had a screen and what she used it for. She mentioned that she used it to play mobile games at home. After some thought, I realized that she was too young for a smartphone. For me, leisure time at the age of five looked different. Although it’s not her fault that she has access to a mobile device, I can’t help but wonder how early exposure to digital screens would affect her development. Unfortunately, this does not make her an outlier. Many kids in this generation have access to technology, for better or for worse. There is no doubt technology has made our lives easier, but to what extent?
Rates of depression and anxiety among adolescents have only increased in the past decade, and is something that can be attributed to increased social media use. Former U.S Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy has called for congressional action and for companies to label platforms with warnings of potential mental distress. I think this a useful moment of progress, especially since social media companies like Meta Platforms have already been found guilty of prioritizing profits over individual safety. Personally, I did not have a smartphone until I was in my sophomore year of high school. At the time, I was upset with my mom’s decision to restrict my cell phone usage and felt like her rationale was an exaggeration. However, recent data and observation has caused me to realize that there was good reason to limit my cell phone use. Children’s brains are the most impressionable from birth until the age of three. Nowadays, many young kids spend their free time using screens, no matter the occasion. I have witnessed several parents give their children iPads and phones as a quick way to occupy them.
Children have no need for a smartphone until they can responsibly use and understand the consequences of using technology. The need for instant gratification pushes many parents to give into the demands of their children. However, it is important to understand that there is a difference between regulated mobile game usage and unregulated cell phone usage. There should be restrictions on cell phone usage for kids who have not yet refined their executive function and decision-making. Excessive access to the internet not only exposes kids to toxic internet culture, but also leads to the likely development of self-esteem issues. They may also lose the ability to meaningfully interact with peers, develop behavioral problems and have difficulty regulating their emotions. Besides the mental and emotional toll, increased phone usage leads to higher rates of obesity and sleep deprivation. If there is anything that should be prioritized for growing children, it is their physical health which largely relies on nutrition, rest and physical activity.
It is understandable that children may have cell phones solely for communication purposes. Once after school activities, clubs and social obligations become routine, it is necessary to have a line of communication with a parent or legal guardian. This need does not usually arise until the age of middle school, though. Parents (like mine) understand that they are responsible for managing their children’s schedules who do not have those kinds of capabilities yet. Lessening the burden of parenting is understandable, especially with more than one child. Still, there are ways to navigate this challenge without introducing potentially dangerous agents of socialization. If certain family dynamics do require that the children have access to a phone, there should be firm boundaries. Ensuring children have limited screen time that does not interfere with sleep schedules is a good start to healthy technology habits.