Case Western Reserve University's independent student news source

The Observer

Case Western Reserve University's independent student news source

The Observer

Case Western Reserve University's independent student news source

The Observer

Sign up for our weekly newsletter!

Pulling the trigger on concealed carry

On Dec. 14 – in the midst of finals season at Case Western Reserve University – students gathered around television screens instead of textbooks. They watched in horror as live media coverage reported the deaths of 20 children and 6 adults in a shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary school in Newtown, Conn.

In the weeks following the tragedy, emotions soon moved from sadness to rage as supporters and critics of tighter gun control laws began drawing lines in the sand, voicing their beliefs about how future massacres could be avoided.

For one side guns are the answer; for the other guns are the problem.

* * *

Two weeks before the Newtown, Conn. Shooting, The Observer learned of a new student group on campus: Spartans for Concealed Carry. This emerging organization is a chapter of Students for Concealed Carry (SCC), which consists of more than 45,000 university community members and citizens nationwide.

The group asserts that state-issued concealed carry handgun licenses should be as applicable on college campuses as they are in most other locations in the state. They note that late-night walks on campus, near potentially dangerous locations like Wade Oval, are made more dangerous by students’ inability to defend themselves with a concealed handgun.

While the group’s debut on campus may seem controversial to many students, staff, and faculty, I believe their emergence and passion is to be commended, regardless of whether you agree with them or not. All too often, the CWRU student body is behind the eight ball when it comes to getting vocal about current issues, so, being at the forefront of discussion is a nice change of pace.

But even as a supporter of concealed carry permits, I do not believe an armed university community is the answer for CWRU.

First, our private institution is fortunate to have its own police force, which is made even more unique by their ability to carry firearms on campus. Other private institutions in Ohio, such as John Carroll University, Baldwin Wallace University, Hiram College, and Ursuline College either employ unarmed security guards or have a police force that is unable to carry firearms.

The decision to bring an armed police force to CWRU was reached following the 2003 shooting at the Peter B. Lewis Building, in which two armed University Circle officers were called to enter and confront Biswanath Halder, who had killed one person and injured two others. As this tragedy demonstrated, having an armed police force means the first-responders to a violent situation are in a position to intervene, rather than wait on the sidelines.

Second, Ohio requires that potential holders of the concealed carry permit be residents of the state for at least 45 days and be at least 21 years of age before they are eligible to apply. Given the age range at CWRU and the varying residential statuses of the student body, this means that not all campus community members will be able to carry weapons. Thus, rather than apply an additional level of protection for the campus, instead it has the potential to create new social classes: those who can carry guns and those who can’t.

Tragedies involving weapons come in many forms, and they often spark as many policy arguments as they do tears. But while the ability to carry firearms on campus seems inappropriate to me, the need to discuss and debate it couldn’t be more important.

Leave a Comment
About the Contributor
Tyler Hoffman, Executive Editor & Publisher
. Fourth-year medical anthropology student Tyler Hoffman has served as Executive Editor and Publisher of The Observer since April 2012. As Executive Editor, Tyler is responsible for establishing and maintaining the direction of The Observer's print and online platforms. Formerly the News Editor, he specializes in research reporting and digital publishing, which are skills he honed as a health writer and editor with the Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine. In addition to his work with The Observer, Tyler chairs the University Media Board and co-chairs the Student Executive Council. In April 2013, he was the recipient of CWRU's Outstanding Member of the Media Award. -- Outside of campus media, Tyler is the Division of Information Technology Services' Student Engagement Leader, in which he helps direct efforts to support students in their use of academic technologies at the university. When not working, Tyler, a passionate fan of food and cooking, enjoys kicking back with his friends and  tasting his way through the Cleveland restaurant scene. Reach Tyler at and on Twitter @tylerehoffman. .

Comments (0)

In an effort to promote dialogue and the sharing of ideas, The Observer encourages members of the university community to respectfully voice their comments below. Comments that fail to meet the standards of respect and mutual tolerance will be removed as necessary.
All The Observer Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *